Spider-Man: Brand New Day Tomatometer 92%+ on July 31, 2026.
💡 What the odds say
Most likely: Tomatometer Below 92% at about a 69% chance — likely.
The market expects Spider-Man: Brand New Day to fall short of a 92% Tomatometer score, with the 'Below 92%' option commanding 69% despite recent positive buzz from cast interviews suggesting a strong fan reception; the single biggest recent shift is a 1-point drop in the Yes (≥92%) probability over 24 hours, potentially reflecting skepticism after mixed reviews for other Marvel projects like 'The Punisher: One Last Kill' (Rotten Tomatoes, May 12).
📊 Base rate: Among the 34 Marvel Cinematic Universe films released before July 2026, roughly 53% achieved a Tomatometer score of 90% or higher, and only about 18% reached 92% or above, making the current 37% probability historically optimistic.
What's driving it
- • The 'Below 92%' candidate leads at 69% partly because recent Marvel projects like 'The Punisher: One Last Kill' received mixed first reviews (Rotten Tomatoes, May 12), which may lower expectations for consistent critical acclaim.
- • The '92% or Higher' side (37%) draws support from the Kalshi News report (Jul 21) calling the film a potential 'instant classic,' boosted by cast comments about pleasing fans and themes of adulthood (Rotten Tomatoes, Jun 17).
Why the front-runners lead
- • The Spider-Man franchise has a strong critical track record, with 'Spider-Man: No Way Home' (2021) reaching 93% on the Tomatometer, suggesting a high bar is plausible.
- • The Rotten Tomatoes article (Jul 20) listing all upcoming Marvel movies highlights 'Brand New Day' as a major release, implying studio confidence in quality control.
Why it's still open
- • The recent availability of Punisher reviews (May 12)—earning a lower Rotten score—may depress expectations for a 92%+ threshold, as Marvel's R-rated experiments have not always resonated with critics.
- • The single 1-point drop in Yes probability over 24 hours, without a clear new catalyst, indicates that traders are reluctant to push odds higher without stronger early screening buzz.
What to watch
- • Early critic screenings or embargo lift dates (typically 1-2 weeks before release) could spike the Yes probability if reactions are strongly positive, or sink it if mixed.
- • The official Rotten Tomatoes score release on July 31 will resolve the market; if the film premieres at a major festival before that, odds may shift sharply as critic consensus emerges.
AI-generated · grounded in recent news + odds · informational only, not advice. Verify on the source platform.
Data from XO Market’s public API, for informational purposes only. PredictPal is not affiliated with any platform and does not facilitate trading.
Discussion
Loading…
How it resolves
Settled by the source platform according to the rules written into this specific market.
ⓘ A market settles under its own written rules, which can lag what looks decided in the news — so the price may not move to 100% the moment an outcome seems obvious.
View the official rules on XO Market ↗Related markets
Are people in the US getting dumber?
The 70% odds that Americans are getting dumber reflect a media-driven narrative linking AI tool use to cognitive decline, but the evidence is mostly anecdotal and lacks rigorous longitudinal data, making the market more a bet on cultural perception than on measurable intelligence.
Yes ≈ 70% chance
Highest box office-grossing movie in 2026 (US/Canada Domestic)
Even though Spider-Man: Brand New Day commands 64%, the field is not truly settled because Toy Story 5 just became 2026's highest-grossing domestic film (IMDb, Jul 21), and The Odyssey is posting exceptional daily numbers, including the year's best Monday stateside (Deadline, Jul 21), showing that late-breaking hits can still close the gap.
7 outcomes
Highest grossing movie in 2026?
The market is essentially flat with both listed candidates at 0% odds, but the biggest recent shift is the record-breaking performance of Christopher Nolan’s ‘The Odyssey’ in late July, which is not a market candidate — creating a glaring mismatch between box office reality and trader sentiment.
2 outcomes
How many consecutive weeks will "KPop Demon Hunters" stay in the Netflix Top 10?
The market is overwhelmingly concentrated on 'Other' at 99%, reflecting near-certainty that the show's record-breaking streak will end at some point beyond the current 11 weeks, with all specific week counts at 0% — a rare consensus that the exact duration is unpredictable despite the show's dominance.
34 outcomes